
Sunny is the real heiress of the Whitmore family, but she was swapped at birth and grew up in foster care while Chloe was raised in the family house as the granddaughter. Sunny has lived this once already, and now she is three years old again with every memory of that life.
Brenda, the nanny, keeps baking cakes for Sunny, and Sunny gives them to Joe, an old homeless man who sleeps by the back fence. The grandparents adore Chloe and treat Sunny as a thief from foster care.
Sunny and Chloe are the same age, and the grandmother has already decided which of them is the Whitmore heiress.
Sunny, the real heiress, is three again with her memories of her first life, and she refuses the cakes that Brenda, the nanny, keeps bringing. She gives them to Joe, an old homeless man outside the back fence, who tells her to keep away from Victor, the family's driver. At the family's painting party, Chloe, the girl the family raised as its heiress, says Sunny copied her, and the grandmother believes Chloe. Ethan, the eldest brother, tries to stop the security guards dragging Sunny toward foster care, and before she goes Sunny asks for the lights to be turned off, which reveals a hidden handprint painting.
Chloe's health keeps getting worse, and the grandmother makes Sunny eat a cake a day while she watches. Police act on an anonymous tip that Lucas, Sunny's brother, is carrying stolen goods in the grandfather's sports car, but the house cameras show he never left home. Ava, Sunny's sister, takes a slice of cake to school for testing, and the results show ash from burnt human hair. Chloe's medicine goes missing and turns up inside Sunny's bunny, so the grandmother locks Sunny in the attic.
Ethan comes back from his trip and moves into the house to guard Sunny. Ava is accused of copying Mia, the top student in her class, and her scholarship is revoked until Sunny spots a camera hidden in a gold pen. Mia admits that a driver with a scar on his left hand paid her to swap the answer tapes, and that scar is Victor's. Then the milk Sunny drinks is found to have ash in it, Brenda is blamed and denies it, and the nurse who was on duty the night Sunny was born quits a week later with a large deposit in her account.
Yes. Once Sunny stops eating the cakes and leaves the grandparents' house with Ethan, her luck starts coming back, as the old library book says it will (episodes 40 and 41).
Victor did. Brenda says so in episode 48, and the brake line Joe kept was cut most of the way through with a knife (episode 31).
Yes. Brenda confesses in episode 48 that she switched the babies at the hospital, and the DNA test confirms Chloe is her daughter.
Yes. The court gives Ethan custody of Sunny in episode 49, and Chloe is moved to a new home in episode 50.
The siblings find their mother's diary, which mentions Brenda asking about her due date and Victor taking over the car from Joe. Sunny and Ethan track down Joe, who says he drove for the family for 20 years, was fired the morning of the crash, and watched Victor burn a note with the mother's signature on it. Joe has kept the brake line from the car in a locker at the old train station, and Ethan sees that it was cut with a knife, most of the way through. A nurse later says a driver with a scar gave her cash to leave the delivery room, and that the woman who walked out holding the baby was the nanny.
Lucas steps in when the grandmother cuts a slice of the 30th cake for Sunny, and Ethan says Sunny will eat nothing made in the house. Ethan's company bid has leaked, so he leaves a fake proposal priced 30% low in Victor's car with a hidden camera, and Victor photographs it for a buyer. The Whitmore Group wins the contract with its real bid, and the grandfather tells Sunny he has room in his heart for her.
Once Sunny lives with Ethan, she laughs more and sleeps better, and an old library book says thirty cakes seal a luck swap that reverses once the feeding stops. The Book of Curses, which logs every cake, is said to be kept in Victor's black leather bag. Chloe needs surgery, but the grandmother refuses it on a fortune teller's word and kneels to beg for Sunny to come back and eat one bite. The grandmother then uses her husband's proxy to remove Ethan as CEO.
Martha, a fire-station volunteer who later became Sunny's foster mother, says a baby was left at her station on a rainy night, and that the baby was Sunny. At the custody hearing, Sunny says she wants to live with Ethan, Lucas and Ava. Victor takes Chloe from the hospital while she has a fever, and Ava's phone tracks Chloe's bracelet to Victor's car, which Ethan follows. Victor runs, and Ethan lets him go to save Chloe, whose lips are turning purple, while Sunny holds her until the ambulance arrives.
A DNA test shows Chloe is Brenda's daughter, and Brenda confesses that she switched the babies at the hospital and that Victor caused the crash. Brenda is arrested for fraud, and Victor is found guilty of premeditated murder and child trafficking. Custody of Sunny goes to Ethan, and Chloe is taken to a new home.
Sunny
The real Whitmore heiress, switched at birth and raised in foster care, who is back at three with her memories of her first life. She is the main character.
Chloe
The girl raised in the Whitmore house as the heiress, and Sunny's rival for the family's love.
Ethan
Sunny's eldest brother, who runs the family company and fights to keep her in the house.
Brenda
The Whitmore nanny, who bakes the cakes and keeps pushing them on Sunny.
Victor
The family's driver, with a scar on his left hand, whom Joe is afraid of.
Joe
An old homeless man who sleeps outside the back fence and is the first person Sunny gives her cakes to.
The last episode is Sunny's first coming-home celebration with Ethan, Lucas and Ava. Their handprint painting now has a print for Sunny in the center, the spot their mother left empty for a baby sister who had not been born yet. Her grandparents are standing outside, and the family decides that is enough.
Because thirty cakes seal the luck swap, and the grandmother pushes the 30th cake on Sunny in episode 33.