
Justin Brooks transfers to St. John's Prep to win a Division I scholarship. Adrian Sterling, the team captain, is the rival Justin has faced on the field, and each of them uses the other's sexuality as an insult.
Richard Sterling, Adrian's father, marries Linda, Justin's mother, and the two boys must share a house and a bedroom. Adrian is angry about it, and he says he cannot stop thinking about Justin.
Justin arrives ready to take Adrian's starting spot.
Justin Brooks, a quarterback, transfers to St. John's Prep, where Adrian Sterling is the team captain and the rival he has faced on the field. Justin has beaten Adrian more than once, and each of them calls the other gay as an insult. Richard Sterling, Adrian's father, marries Linda, Justin's mother, and tells the boys they will share the big bedroom upstairs. He threatens to freeze Adrian's credit cards and take back his sports car if Adrian refuses.
Adrian refuses to accept the backup role. The coach sets up a pass-pressure test and moves Adrian to wide receiver, but Adrian says he would rather retire than catch Justin's passes. The two face off in one-on-one drills, where the loser has to leave the team. Emma, Adrian's girlfriend, warns Justin to stay away from her boyfriend, and later she sends men after Justin's throwing arm.
Justin is driven to an abandoned warehouse in a car with no plates, where Emma and her men hold him down. Adrian finds him there and pulls him out. Adrian ends things with Emma, and her father vows to make Justin's life a living hell.
Charles Ashford, a rich donor to St. John's, wants Justin gone and tells the principal to ruin him within a week. The principal orders Justin to throw the exhibition game and threatens to expose him as gay if he refuses. Justin agrees at first, and Adrian accuses him of planning to throw the game. Justin later decides he will not lose on purpose, and in the game he is knocked out, so the other team is disqualified and the two teams will meet again next month.
The principal keeps pressing Justin to lose, and Justin refuses until the principal tries to force himself on him. Adrian arrives, beats the principal, and takes Justin out of the room. Afterward Justin tells Adrian about the blackmail, and he admits he has always been jealous of Adrian.
The principal ends up in hospital, and Richard tells his son he is proud of him. Adrian says he did it by his own choice and takes a suspension from football, so the blame stays off Justin. The principal then threatens Adrian, claiming Charles Ashford stands behind him, and Adrian warns him to keep quiet. After the principal is arrested, Adrian's suspension is lifted.
Recruiters from Ohio State come to watch practice, and they have room for only one quarterback. They want Justin, and Adrian needs the spot to prove himself to his father. In the drills each of them loses on purpose to give the other the place, until Justin realizes what Adrian has done. They agree to compete fairly and let the field decide.
Someone takes pictures of the two of them at practice, and the photos begin to circulate. A group of students corners Justin, and Adrian steps in to protect him. Adrian tells the whole school that Justin is his stepbrother and that anyone who messes with him will answer to Adrian. Later Adrian says he wants to be with Justin, and the two of them spend the night together.
Justin does not come home one night, and Linda asks where he is while Justin hides in Adrian's room. Charles Ashford gets the school board involved, and the school tells the coach to cut Justin or forfeit every game. Justin offers to step down only if Adrian gets the quarterback spot, and Adrian says he will quit too. The team refuses to play, the coach gives in, and Justin leads a last-second win in the final game, after which the police take the Ashford away and Ohio State opens a second spot for both boys.
In the final episode Richard and Linda tell Adrian and Justin that they are okay with the two of them being together. Ohio State has opened another slot, so both of them will play there next year and then aim for the pros. For Adrian, who began the series calling Justin a cheat, the ending puts him on the same side as Justin with his family's blessing.
Justin Brooks
A transfer quarterback who becomes Adrian's stepbrother and the team's starting quarterback.
Adrian Sterling
The St. John's team captain and Justin's rival, who becomes his stepbrother when their parents marry.
Emma
Adrian's girlfriend, who turns against Justin and sends men after his throwing arm.
Richard Sterling
Adrian's father, who marries Linda, controls the family money and pushes Adrian toward the pros.
Linda
Justin's mother, who marries Richard and moves into the Sterling house.
Charles Ashford
A rich donor to St. John's who wants Justin removed from the school.
No. He decides not to lose on purpose (episode 23), and in the game he is knocked out while the other team is disqualified (episode 24).
Because the principal has been blackmailing Justin and tries to force himself on him (episode 27). Adrian arrives and beats him, and the principal ends up in hospital (episodes 28 and 30).
Both of them, in the end. Justin refuses to take a spot Adrian gave up (episode 38), and Ohio State opens a second slot so both can go (episode 51).
Yes. In the final episode Richard and Linda say they are okay with it, and the two of them are still together and heading to Ohio State (episode 51).
Because Charles Ashford gets the school board involved, and the school says it will forfeit every game unless Justin is cut (episode 46).